Disney World’s Iconic Carrot Cake Cookie Sees Big Changes!

We’re not really sure how to tell you this, so we’re just gonna come out with it: Walt Disney World’s beloved Carrot Cake Cookie  has been ‘updated.’ Changed. Reinvented. Altered unnecessarily. However you say it, the truth remains: the Carrot Cake Cookie as we knew it is no more.

Let’s get into this. You can still find the Carrot Cake Cookie at Trolley Car Treats — Disney’s Hollywood Studios’ Starbucks location. (Since Sweet Spells closed a couple of weeks ago, Trolley Car is the only location where you can pick up this popular treat!) It costs $3.99 (or a DDP snack credit), so it’s a relatively reasonable price.

Carrot Cake Cookie

Carrot Cake Cookie

But will you want to? The old Carrot Cake Cookie celebrated both components of perfect carrot cake: the cake and the cream cheese frosting. The ratio was spot-on: thick frosting between thin, cake-like cookies. Basically a huge whoopie pie with all the right proportions.

Carrot Cake Cookie

Carrot Cake Cookie

Now, it looks like this:

New Carrot Cake Cookie

New Carrot Cake Cookie

If you’re thinking “Can we have some frosting with that cake?”, the answer is yes. Sort of.

New Carrot Cake Cookie

New Carrot Cake Cookie

See? Its in there, peeking out from between two seriously inflated carrot cake cookies. But to say we’re underwhelmed is an understatement.

The New Carrot Cake Cookie

The New Carrot Cake Cookie

There’s some good news, and it’s all about the cake (in case you couldn’t tell!). The flavor and the texture of the cake remains the same, so if you’re a bigger fan of the cake than the frosting, you will not be disappointed.

Carrot Cake Cookie

Carrot Cake Cookie

Moist and lightly seasoned, the carrot cake itself is yummy. And like the older version, which we always felt was more cake than cookie, this one is definitely cake.

All carrot cake

All carrot cake

But if you know us, we’re all about the cream cheese frosting. And, really, if we want to compare this to a whoopie pie, it needs a lot more frosting in that context, too.

Here it is, the biggest crime committed by the new Carrot Cake Cookie: less frosting than the original – even with the dramatic increase in cake!

Cream Cheese Frosting

Cream Cheese Frosting

We love the sweet and tangy frosting, we just need more of it. Like double. Easily.

Cream Cheese Frosting

Cream Cheese Frosting

The ratio of cake to frosting is better toward the middle of the sandwich, but it’s still not enough. The sweet frosting is necessary to balance out the carrot-y taste of the cake, so what you’re left with after you eat it is a strong carrot aftertaste.

Carrot Cake Cookie to Frosting ratio

Carrot Cake Cookie to Frosting ratio

Bottom line: if you’re into the cake and can take or leave the cream cheese frosting, the updated Carrot Cake Cookie is made for you. But if you’re like us — or really wanted to try the famed Carrot Cake Cookie of yore — you won’t get the experience you expected. And that’s a bummer.

New Carrot Cake Cookie

New Carrot Cake Cookie

Why?! Why must something so good be changed into something so mediocre?

Don’t get me wrong. I’ll totally still eat it. But if you need me, I’ll be in the corner whining for a while. And hatching a plan to get a cast member at Trolley Car to somehow sneak me some more frosting… .

Don’t Miss Out on the ALL the Best Snacks Walt Disney World Has to Offer!

Get four awesome e-Books FULL of Disney park dining advice, bundled for 30% off the already discounted price! Yep, we’ve scoured the parks to find any and all snack choices — from the mundane to the spectacular — and we tell you all about them (with full-color pictures!) in our snack guides! These are updated every year, so you know your guide will be perfect for your upcoming trip, and they’re bundled with our DFB Guide to WDW Dining!

2018 DFBandSnacksBundle

This money-saving bundle includes all of the following:

All four are being sold together — for 30% off the already hugely discounted bundle price. Use code BUNDLE18 at check out to get the discount. It’s a $63 value for under $30!!

With this Bundle of e-books you’ll have everything you need at your fingertips to plan the best Disney World vacation ever. And with our handy e-book format, you can download the Guides to all of your electronic devices and take them with you wherever you go!

And with our 100% money-back guarantee, what do you have to lose?

What do you think of the new Carrot Cake Cookie? Commiserate or celebrate in the comments! 

Comments

  1. Stacy says

    Wow, that’s so weird. My husband had the new version twice in the last 5 days and it didn’t look like that at all. The frosting layer was gargantuan! Monumental! The whole thing weighed as much as a small child! Lol He was not disappointed by the change, to say the least.

  2. Amy Curneal says

    Will they let you purchase extra frosting?! That’s my fav part too!!

  3. DFB Sarah says

    Amy, as far as we know, there’s no option to buy extra frosting. But that would be awesome!

  4. DFB Sarah says

    Stacy, thanks for the info! We’ll keep our eyes peeled to see if the frosting issue is just a matter of consistency.

  5. says

    Honestly, I know everyone has their traditions and food experiences while in Disney World, but I just don’t get why everyone gets their knickers in a twist every time they change a COOKIE! Disney is constantly changing up their rides, food and etc. Times they are a changing and you have to go with the flow……I can honestly say I had to try the infamous carrot cake cookie at the Writer’s Stop a few years ago and was underwhelmed. It was half frozen and for me it was meh! Disney World is spending time with your family, forgetting about your burdens that are waiting at home for you and just relaxing. Hopefully, WDW is way more to you than just a cookie!

  6. Siera says

    They were actually selling this new weird version when Sweet Spells was still open. I went in April and was like …huh? What is this thing? Haha. I’m a bit sad that I never got to try the original legendary one ☹️

  7. Kendall says

    I’m not going to get upset over a minor change to a vegetable-based cookie. I’ve learned that DFB’s idea of a delicious dessert does not at all align with my own anyways. I tried the Oreo Whoopi pie they raved about and found it to be incredibly bland and had to throw it away after a couple bites. To each their own though.

  8. Doug says

    Awesome!! Always thought the previous cookies ratio was way to high on the frosting.

  9. jaypeacemyth says

    As a counterpoint to the “all this over a cookie?” debate, let me remind people that the middle name of this blog IS “Food”. It’s probably in their bylaws that when they see a change they deem for the worse in any food-related item, then it is their job, nay, their mission, to inform the public so that people may make informed decisions when they visit the parks.

    That being said, it IS only a cookie, people. Grab a Sprinkles frosting shot if you really need your fix. It’s not like someone changed the formula for Häagen-Dazs vanilla icecream or somethin… Wait. What? They did! NOOOOooo0000oooººº•••!!!

  10. Greg says

    I had one this morning and I though the ratio was just fine. I love cream cheese frosting, but a lot of it can be overwhelming. The cake was delicious and the frosting was as well. Never had the old one but I didn’t see anything wrong with this.

  11. Kelly M says

    There’s a special place in the fiery depths of you know where for the person that ok’d this change.

  12. Courtney says

    So sad!!! This was the last food item I shared with my grandma on her “Farewell Florida” trip (she had moved down there with her husband MANY years ago to be closer to his family, and after he passed she decided to move back home to be with her family). It was big enough to split 3 ways and all of us got just enough. I came home craving it and attempted to make my own, but they weren’t as good. It’s a good memory I’ll have from that trip, especially since my grandma can’t travel anymore and will not be going back to WDW. As long as the flavors are the same I’ll be happy….but if it’s smaller my husband might need to get his own lol.

  13. says

    I only had the chance to experience the joy that was the original carrot cake cookie once. Now I’ll just be looking back with fond memories! I wish they would have made the cake part smaller and increased the icing
    : )

  14. Ron says

    My wife and I just bought this new-fangled carrot cake cookie contraption for the first time and she said to me, “what’s AJ talking about? This things horrible…”. There was way to much cake with this bad boy. This is definitely not a cookie, it is a handheld cake. The frosting was delicious, but there needed to be way more. Don’t worry AJ, I had your back and told her you wouldnt steer us wrong. Lol

  15. says

    Ron — Ha ha!! That is the BEST! Yes, these used to be amazing, but, you never know what Disney is going to do! Thanks for having my six on this one!

  16. Sarah says

    We had the new carrot cake cookie last week and there we had a lot more frosting than what you have pictured. It was so good! My husband LOVED it and would not stop talking about it. He wants me to somehow recreate this treat for his birthday! I’ll recreate another trip to Disney for his birthday where he can get another lol!

  17. Ruth says

    Oh no this was top of the list of snacks we wanted to try in August, this looks no where near as big or appealing as before

  18. laura says

    I know it is just a cookie. But it was a special cookie that I loved so much that my parents would make special trips into Hollywood Studios to bring back containers of these cookies. I had the new version last week and it is so different. And meh. And I’m sad. And it is that big of a deal to me- with the changes in this one cookie I see no reason to journey Hollywood Studios- at least not until Star Wars land is completed- as the park has been managed so poorly lately (e.g., why not wait until Toy Story Land is finished before closing the Great Movie Ride?)

  19. Chris says

    Did they also change it at Magic Kingdom? That being said, I thought the old version had slightly too much frosting, but this looks like it would be too little. Hopefully they are still working out the kinks and will get the proportions right because I always did want more cake.

  20. Chris says

    Oh and to those that dont understand the uproar, I am guessing you never had one of these awesome cookies.

  21. Ruth says

    Am I the only one who is chuffed that there is more cake and less frosting then …

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *