You might find yourself drenched in sweat in Florida, but the pumpkin-flavored treats tell the story of a different season. It’s…FALL!?

It’s TIME

Pumpkin wreaths are up in Magic Kingdom, Mickey’s Not-So-Scary Halloween Party is back, and Halloween treats are starting to arrive. We actually grabbed one of the NEW Halloween treats available in Magic Kingdom and it turned us ORANGE. But was all of the food dye (and mess) worth it?

Introducing the NEW Oh, My Gourd Cupcake! This thing is one of those “gotta get it for the Instagram” treats for SURE. The treat is made of a pumpkin spice cupcake with cinnamon cream cheese icing finished with dark chocolate ears.

Oh, My GOURD

This particular cupcake is over at Main Street Bakery and is one that’ll be available during regular Magic Kingdom park hours, as well as during Mickey’s Not-So-Scary Halloween Party.

If you want to try it, it’ll set you back $6.29.

Fall Treat Time

But is the cost worth it? Well, there are a few things you should be warned about before getting it. The pumpkin spice cupcake itself has a LOT of that spiced flavor (not “hot” spicy, but filled with spices and flavors of fall). You can really taste the nutmeg and spice in it. We would compare it more to a spice cake than a pumpkin cupcake, so keep that in mind.

You could taste a hint of the pumpkin, but it wasn’t very strong. In fact, we kind of wish there was MORE pumpkin in this one! It’s ironic that a pumpkin-shaped treat really didn’t taste all that much like pumpkin.

We Wish You Had More Pumpkin!

The cupcake itself is a little on the dryer side, but it’s pretty good as far as cupcakes go. The cinnamon cream cheese icing is gooooooood and fluffy. It really carried through that cinnamon flavor, but in the best way possible.

The buttercream on top is quite sweet. But our favorite part by far was the dark chocolate on top in the form of little ears! They melt in your mouth and add a great flavor balance to the treat overall. We wish there was actually more chocolate in here!

A Look Inside

Overall, if you’re looking for a cinnamon spice cake cupcake, this is a pretty decent pick. Plus it’s pretty adorable. BUT if you’re looking for a strong pumpkin punch, you like your cupcakes to be very moist, or you don’t like cinnamon, this is probably a “skip” for you.

If you do get this treat, be WARNED. It takes NO prisoners when it comes to mess and orange dye, so be prepared with wipes and napkins!

Oh MY

Would you give this treat a try? Tell us in the comments! We’re making our way around Disney World to check out ALL the fall things, so check back with us for more updates.

In the meantime, you can click here to see ALL the Halloween merchandise you can get in Disney World right now, or click here to see our page of all of our reviews for the 2022 Fall and Halloween treats.

Click here to check out the TINIEST Halloween decor we’ve ever seen!

Halloween at Walt Disney World

• Mickey’s Not-So-Scary Halloween Party Has Returned to Magic Kingdom and We’ve Got the ONLY Guide You Need!

• See the Full List of PRICES and DATES for Mickey’s Not-So-Scary Halloween Party

• Full List of Dates That Have SOLD OUT for Mickey’s Not-So-Scary Halloween Party

• Get All of the Latest Updates on Mickey’s Not-So-Scary Halloween Party

• See Our Photos and Reviews for ALL of the Fall and Halloween Treats in Disney World

• Start Your Halloween Shopping NOW With These Disney Items Online

• Check Out the Disney Halloween Ears That Dropped Online

• Get a Look at ALL of the Halloween Merchandise You Can Buy in Disney World

• Can You Resist These NEW Halloween Shirts?!

• A Halloween Candy Shortage Means You’ll Need Trick-or-Treating Alternatives and We Can Help

• See How Much It Costs to Do Disney World at Halloween in 2022

• Learn About the Halloween Scavenger Hunt Coming to Disney World

Join the DFB Newsletter To Get All the Latest Disney News Delivered Right to Your Inbox Click Here to Subscribe

Is this treat the stuff of your dreams or nightmares? Tell us in the comments!

TRENDING NOW