News! The Return of PLASTIC CHEESE at Casey’s Corner!


It’s BACK, y’all!! PLASTIC CHEESE has returned to Casey’s Corner in the Magic Kingdom! Well…sort of.

If you’ve been following this story (or saga, as it were), Plastic Cheese is pretty much my all time favorite condiment of ALL TIME. Sure, Disney calls it “Cheese Sauce,” but we all know that the name Plastic Cheese comes from nothing but my deep and abiding love for this bright orange-yellow, melty, gooey, “this-probably-isn’t-real-food-but-if-it’s-wrong-I-don’t-want-to-be-right” cheddar cheese sauce that you could use to top anything from those Hot Dogs at Casey’s to French Fries at Cosmic Ray’s and so many things beyond. Better yet, you’d often find it as a self-serve component at various Toppings Bars in Counter Service restaurants.

But in 2015, Plastic Cheese disappeared — almost overnight — from Counter Service spots all across Disney World. Though we have seen it sporadically showing up here and there as a topping on items like the Plaza Loaded Fries and the French Fries with Pulled Pork and Cheese at Flame Tree Barbecue, the days of self-serve Plastic Cheese were clearly long gone.

BUT!! We JUST spotted Plastic Cheese up for grabs once again at Casey’s Corner!!

Plastic Cheese at Casey's Corner!!

Plastic Cheese at Casey’s Corner!!

Now, there are some changes: you still won’t find Plastic Cheese on the Casey’s Toppings Bar alongside the sauerkraut, onions, and more. Instead, you’ll see it on the menu. For a buck. (Yeah, yeah. I know.)

Casey's Corner Menu

Casey’s Corner Menu

Still, you receive a REALLY decent sized bowl of it. Plenty to top your hot dog or dip your fries in! Or just, you know, eat straight up with a spoon ;) . (No, you would never do that. I know.)

Bowl of Plastic Cheese

Bowl of Plastic Cheese

In my opinion? That is one dollar WELL SPENT, my friends!

We don’t know how long this will last, so get on in there if you’re a cheese fan like me!

WOO HOO!!! What do you think of this reappearance of PLASTIC CHEESE at Casey’s Corner? Please let us know with a comment!


  1. Courtney says

    YAY!!!!! I hope they keep it around for my trip in November. The pre-packaged cheese they sell with the pretzels is good, but the true plastic cheese is the best!

  2. Essie says

    YES!!!! I love this stuff ( even though it’s no good for us), but hey, it’s vacation at WDW, so eating is on vaca, too! It prob. disappeared because somebody didn’t use common sense and sued because they got burned. I’m dumb, so give me money! Now you have to pay for it and the container may have a warning that it may be hot. I’m just glad it’s back!

  3. Stephanie says

    I’m not a huge fan of plastic cheese, but I had to tell you how you made me literally LOL! Keep the reviews coming, AJ. Love the DFB!

  4. Kara says

    I bought the cheese sauce when I was there a week ago. It is nothing like what the self serve was. Has a more queso/nacho cheese flavor to it. Still so sad about this change!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *