Boo…to YOU! Boo to you, and you, and you, and you…Happy Halloween! We are back at Magic Kingdom for even more Mickey’s Not-So-Scary Halloween Party fun. Of course, that also means we are trying out even more food, so you know what items are a must-get and what items you might want to skip.
Mickey’s Not-So-Scary Halloween Party is a separately ticketed event that happens on select evenings through October 31st. This family-friendly Halloween event features trick-or-treating, rare character meet and greets, exclusive entertainment, and over 45 themed treats you can grab. Let’s head over to Cosmic Ray’s Starlight Cafe for a party-exclusive item!
We are trying out a NEW item over at Cosmic Ray’s Starlight Cafe. May we introduce the Not a Poisoned Apple Slushy, which you can grab for $6.49. This drink is non-alcoholic and ONLY available during Mickey’s Not-So-Scary Halloween Party. It is frozen apple cider topped with cinnamon whipped cream and sour gummy candy.
We’re not gonna lie, we were a bit surprised by the color, but let’s dig in! The slushy had lots of green apple flavor. It reminded us of the Jolly Rancher green apple flavor, without being quite as sweet. It was a bit more on the sour side. Essentially, it tastes like a frozen apple juice, which we are here for! The cinnamon whipped cream had lots of cinnamon flavor and it kind of tasted like the frosting they put on top of the brown sugar cinnamon pop tart.
The sour gummies didn’t end up adding a whole lot for us beyond looking pretty cute on top. They were sitting in the cinnamon whipped cream, and we aren’t sure the flavors of sour gummy worms and cinnamon whipped cream work very well together. But it’s cute with the whole apple theme.
We definitely recommend mixing this slushy together with the whipped cream as it gives it a more apple cider flavor. Also, if you are really excited about this drink, we also recommend bringing your own straw as it is a bit hard to mix with the paper straw! Overall, we enjoyed this slushy, and it definitely tasted like we were drinking a frozen apple cider once we got it mixed together. Stay tuned to DFB for all your Disney World news!
REVIEW: We Found 2 Surprisingly GREAT Snacks at One of Magic Kingdom’s Commonly Avoided Restaurants
IT'S SPOOK-TACULAR!
Get ready for the spookiest season of the year at Disney World with our guide -- Halloween at Disney World: DFB's Spook-tacular Guide!
From the thrills of Mickey's Not-So-Scary Halloween Party to the enchanting resort decorations that'll send shivers down your spine, our guide is packed with tips and tricks to help you squeeze every ounce of ghoulish fun out of your visit. Plus, we've got the inside scoop on all the limited-time-only bone-chilling activities happening across the parks!
Get the Halloween at Disney World: DFB's Spook-tacular Guide to make your frightfully delightful adventure even more magical!
Halloween at Walt Disney World
Photos AND Reviews: ALL the Fall and Halloween Treats in Disney World!
Join the DFB Newsletter To Get All the Latest Disney News Delivered Right to Your Inbox Click Here to Subscribe
Are you adding the Not a Poisoned Apple Slushy to your list? Let us know in the comments!





Our handy (and portable!) ebook guides make sure you get the best deals and can plan a vacation of a lifetime.

TRENDING NOW
Heads up! Disney World prices will likely increase soon -- here's what we know.
A familiar face is coming BACK to Disney World, and we couldn't be more excited!
We've rounded up every change happening at Disney's Hollywood Studios in October!
It may be a splurge, but this Amazon accessory is a game-changer for your Disney...
Something NEW has appeared at Disney World's new lounge.
Understand the basics of Lightning Lane Multi Pass but want to be sure you're mastering...
We visited Pinocchio Village Haus in Magic Kingdom, and we are bringing you our FULL...
Disney has FINALLY just released the menus for the 2026 EPCOT International Food and Wine...
Check out the new Beauty and the Beast collection that just landed online!
A lot has changed with airport security in recent months.
Time to run to Target!
Disney has released the DATES for the 2027 EPCOT Flower & Garden Festival!
I’ve taken my fair share of Disney Cruises in my day, and I’m here to...
Disney World just announced the Celebrity Narrators for the EPCOT Festival of the Holiday!
Disney World hotels are seeing a lot of change this winter.
These Disney+ perks are disappearing SOON!
We're bringing you our first look at Dolly Parton's new SongTeller hotel in Nashville, Tennessee!
Disney just announced the lineup for the Eat to the Beat Concert Series!
Full menus have been announced for the Hurly-Burly!
The Disney Wish will have a 'Frozen'-inspired restaurant onboard! Get details here.