We’re on a mission to find out which 50th Anniversary treat is the BEST in Disney World.
To find out, we’re holding the Ultimate 50th Anniversary Disney Snack Bracket Challenge. We asked our readers to decide between a LOT of 50th Anniversary eats and treats, voting for their favorites throughout the challenge. We’ve taken a look at rounds two and three already, so now let’s see what happened in round four!
To start out, we had the battle of the dome cakes! The chocolate-y Mickey Mouse Dome Cake from Gaston’s Tavern went up against the 50th Celebration Mickey Mouse Dome from Creature Comforts. In this case, the bright colors and more exciting theming won out, with the Celebration Dome beating out Gaston’s creation by 24%. Does it hurt that the Celebration Dome has a whole brownie as its base? Probably not.
The next match-up was quite a bit closer, with just a 16% margin. It was the 50th Celebration Spring Rolls from the Spring Roll Wagon against the Petit Stump Cake from Roaring Fork. In the end, the spring rolls won out with 58% of the votes! That makes these spring rolls the only savory snack left in the competition, up against a whole bunch of very sweet opponents.
The margins only got smaller from here, as we matched up the 50th Celebration Mickey Premium Bar from Drinkwallah against the 50th Celebration Petit Cake from Amorette’s Patisserie. Although the Mickey bar is an absolute classic, it couldn’t quite beat the amazing geode decorations on the petit cake. Amorette’s cake won by just 6% of the votes!
We saved the CLOSEST match-up for the end. It’s the Showtime with Jose from Aloha Isle against the Happy Haunts Milkshake from Columbia Harbour House. The donut-topped milkshake came close to winning, but Showtime with Jose ended up sealing its victory with just a 2% lead! Showtime with Jose has been a surprisingly strong contender, especially since it wasn’t even our reporter’s favorite 50th-themed drink at Aloha Isle.
The competition is getting really stiff now! Don’t forget to go vote for your favorites on Instagram — head to our stories to find the polls. And keep following DFB so we can let you know the results of the next round.
Click Here to Check Out ALL the Treats and Snacks We Tried for the 50th in Disney World
Walt Disney World 50th Anniversary Details and Info
See Photos & Reviews of All of Disney World’s 50th Anniversary Eats and Treats
Check Out the 50th Anniversary Merchandise Released Online
Get a Look at Some of the 50th Anniversary Merchandise Released in the Parks
Click HERE for Your Guide to Disney World’s 50th Anniversary Celebration
Join the DFB Newsletter To Get All the Latest Disney News Delivered Right to Your Inbox Click here to Subscribe
Which snack do you think has what it takes to win it all? Let us know in the comments!






Our handy (and portable!) ebook guides make sure you get the best deals and can plan a vacation of a lifetime.

TRENDING NOW
November is going to be a big month in the Disney universe,
New food has arrived in Magic Kingdom!
Check out the new store that just opened in Disney Springs!
Banana Ball is coming back to Disney World in 2027!
It looks like it's going to be a VERY wet winter in Florida for one...
Watch out! These five Disney World attractions will be closed in November!
There are some great Disney deals on Amazon this weekend!
There's a new dining experience on the Disney Adventure!
A TON is coming to Disney+ and Hulu in November.
Tons of holiday kitchen items and candles are coming to ALDI!
Disney filed a patent that could solve a huge PhotoPass problem.
BIG changes are coming to EPCOT's 2027 Festival of the Arts!
We're breaking down the latest round of Disney rumors!
All these Disney items are on sale!
Dude Perfect is teaming up with Disney for TONS of new content!
A Hollywood Studios attraction is closing AGAIN -- here's what we know.
Disney fans are divided on this popular Disney World tradition and they are not holding...
I went on Amazon for one Haunted Mansion candle and somehow ended up trying to...
These two airlines made big changes!
I keep having unfortunate experiences at one popular Disney World restaurant. WHAT is going on?!