Disney has SO many classic snacks that we can’t pick a favorite — so we asked our readers on Instagram!

We recently brought you a video of the best Disney snacks in 2021. But which one is the winner? Well, that’s for you to decide! Here’s the results for Round 1 of our Best Snacks of 2021 Bracket.

First up are two fan favorites from Gideon’s Bakehouse. The Original Chocolate Chip Cookie beat the Triple Chocolate Chip Cookie by a landslide! But some people were REALLY conflicted. As one reader put it, ““Why. Must. I. Choose!!!!!!”.

Over at another Disney Springs dessert spot, we pitted Everglazed Donuts and Cold Brew’s Reese’s Nitro against its Maple Bacon Donut. The Reese’s Nitro managed to pull ahead and take this one!

Let’s head into Disney’s Hollywood Studios! Next up is the Carrot Cake Cookie from Trolley Car Cafe vs. the Wookie Cookie from Backlot Express. This was a really close one, but the Wookie Cookie won by just 2%!

In another close vote, the Cheshire Cat Tail from Cosmic Ray’s managed to beat out the Peanut Butter Pie from Contempo Cafe.

Time to face off some floats! The Kakamora Float from Aloha Isle conquered the Peter Pan Float from Storybook Treats.

Meanwhile, at L’Artisan des Glaces, the Macaron Ice Cream Sandwich crushed the Brioche Ice Cream Sandwich!

In another sweet showdown, the Strawberry Shortcake Ice Cream Sandwich from Dino-Bites lost to the Dole Whip Nachos from Marketplace Snacks. How can you NOT love a Dole Whip + nachos combo?!

Off to the Milk Stand in Star Wars: Galaxy’s Edge! Our readers must not be Green Milk fans, because over 80% of them picked Blue Milk instead.

The Grey Stuff Cupcake from Gaston’s Tavern will move on to the next round, while the Butterfinger Cupcake from Rosie’s All-American Cafe is left behind.

This was a tough one for some readers, but ultimately, Gaston’s Cinnamon Roll from Gaston’s Tavern beat out the School Bread from Kringla Bakeri og Cafe. One reader protested, “How are you going to do this to me! My top 2 favorite Disney snacks!”. But that’s 2 for 2, Gaston! No one wins like Gaston, after all.

Our readers chose the Zebra Domes at Kidani Village’s Johari Treasures over the Pongu Lumpia from Pongu Pongu…

…and the ‘Ohana Bread Pudding from Kona Cafe over the Nutella Waffle Sandwich from Sleepy Hollow Refreshments. This was another HARD choice. One reader said it was “the world’s most impossible decision” and another simply stated, “What???? I refuse to choose. Refuse.” We feel your pain!

Ultimately, the Charcuterie Board from BaseLine Tap House fell to the Butter Chicken Poutine from The Daily Poutine…

…and the Spring Rolls from Magic Kingdom’s Spring Roll Cart bested the Cheeseburger Pods from Satu’li Canteen! One of our readers told us, “Ugh this is the hardest one!” They’re both SO good.

Time to talk carbs! The Creamy Brie Bread Bowl from L’Art de la Cuisine Francaise fell to the Mac and Cheese Tots from Friar’s Nook, but not without a fight.

Lastly, the Corn Dog Nuggets from Westward Ho beat the Hand-Dipped Corn Dog from Sleepy Hollow Refreshments. How are we supposed to choose?!

That wraps up Round 1 of our Best Snacks of 2021 Bracket. We can’t wait to see which snacks make it through next week! If you want to vote, head over to our Instagram and keep a close eye on our stories. We’ll be back with a Round 2 update next week!

Here Are Disney’s Most Overrated and Underrated Snacks, According to You!

What do you think of these picks for Round 1? Let us know in the comments!